Pile of gold bullion coins from several government mints

Selling Gold in Florida: ID, Records, the Scrap Hold and Taxes

Selling gold to a Florida dealer means showing government photo ID, giving a thumbprint and signing a statement that the items are yours, and, for scrap gold and silver such as used jewelry, the dealer must then hold the items for 30 calendar days before reselling or melting them. Investment bullion is not subject to that hold. Those rules come from Chapter 538 of the Florida Statutes, which regulates secondhand dealers. Florida does not tax your profit, but the IRS does. Here is what happens at the counter, why it happens, and how to prepare before you sell.

What Florida law requires when you sell gold to a dealer

Under section 538.04, the dealer completes a transaction form at the time of the sale. The record covers the time, date and place, a description of what was bought (metal type, weight, content if known, and any marks or serial numbers), digital photographs of the items, and a description of the seller: full name, address, workplace, phone numbers, physical description and a clean right thumbprint. The dealer must check a government-issued photo ID, such as a driver license or military ID, and record the type, the issuing agency and the number. You also sign a statement that you own the goods or are entitled to sell them.

Within 24 hours, the dealer delivers that record to local law enforcement, usually electronically. The purpose is theft prevention, so stolen property can be traced, and it is separate from any tax reporting. The dealer keeps the transaction form for at least three years. We ask every seller for photo ID because the law requires it, not because of a house preference.

The statute also puts weight on honesty at the counter. Knowingly giving a false ID or a false ownership statement and being paid is a third-degree felony when the payment is under $300 and a second-degree felony at $300 or more.

The 30-day holding period

The hold applies to gold and silver scrap, such as jewelry and broken pieces a dealer buys and may melt. Section 538.06 says a secondhand dealer may not sell, barter, exchange, alter, use or otherwise dispose of precious metals, gemstones or jewelry until 30 calendar days after acquiring them. The main exception is when the person who originally sold the goods wants to redeem or repurchase them and the dealer can produce the original record. Separately, a law enforcement officer with probable cause that an item is stolen can place a written hold of up to 90 days. Investment bullion, meaning bars and coins, is not subject to the hold, so a dealer may resell it right away.

For a scrap seller, the hold explains pricing. The dealer carries the market risk for a month and cannot sell to lock in a price. As an illustration, a 3% move in gold during the hold changes the value of a $10,000 lot by $300 in either direction. That is one reason dealer offers sit below melt value. Melt value is simply what the metal is worth at spot, not a price any buyer can guarantee. When you compare offers, ask for each one in writing as a percentage of melt, and ask which spot price is being used. Our post on this week’s gold slide shows how quickly spot can move. Bullion works differently. With no hold, a dealer can resell it right away, so bullion offers follow spot and the product premium more closely.

Florida selling rules at a glance

RuleWhat it means for youStatute
Photo IDA government-issued photo ID is checked and its number recorded538.04(2)
Thumbprint and photosYour right thumbprint is taken and the dealer photographs the items538.04(1)
Ownership statementYou sign that you own the goods or may legally sell them538.04(3)
Report to policeThe record goes to law enforcement within 24 hours538.04(1)
Holding period30 calendar days for scrap gold and silver, gemstones and jewelry (not bullion)538.06(1)
Record retentionThe dealer keeps transaction records at least 3 years538.06(5)
False ID or ownership claimThird-degree felony under $300, second-degree felony at $300 or more538.04(4)

Taxes after you sell gold in Florida

Federal tax: the 28% collectibles rule

The IRS treats coins and other metals as collectibles. Your gain is what you received minus your basis, which is generally what you paid. If you held the item for more than one year, the gain is long-term, and net collectibles gains are taxed at a maximum of 28%. If you held it for one year or less, the gain is short-term and taxed as ordinary income. Because 28% is a ceiling, it is not a flat rate that applies to everyone.

SituationFederal treatment
Held one year or lessShort-term gain, taxed at ordinary income rates
Held more than one yearLong-term collectibles gain, taxed at a maximum of 28%
Inherited or gifted itemsBasis is set under different rules (IRS points to Publication 551)
Loss on personal-use items such as worn jewelryNot deductible

Gains are reported on Form 8949 and Schedule D. If you inherited the items, keep any estate paperwork or appraisal, since the basis follows different rules than an item you bought yourself.

Florida tax

Florida’s constitution bars a state income tax on individuals, so there is no Florida return for your gain. Sales tax is a buyer-side issue. Florida exempted gold, silver and platinum bullion from sales tax on August 1, 2025, as the Department of Revenue confirmed in a tax notice, and we explain the details in our guide to the bullion exemption.

Will the dealer send the IRS a 1099-B?

Usually not for an ordinary sale. The IRS instructions for Form 1099-B exempt many precious metal sales: a sale is not reportable if the metal is in a form the CFTC has not approved for futures delivery, or if the quantity is below the minimum needed for an approved futures contract. Sales by the same customer within 24 hours are added together to test that threshold. The IRS gives the example of a single gold coin when the futures contracts call for at least 25 coins. No form does not mean no tax, though. A gain is taxable whether or not anyone reports it.

Checklist: before you sell gold in Jacksonville

  1. Bring a government-issued photo ID. The dealer is required to record it.
  2. Sort your items by metal and note any karat or fineness marks, such as 14K or .999.
  3. Find receipts or records of what you paid. They set your basis and can lower the gain you report.
  4. Ask for each offer in writing, stated as a percentage of melt value, and ask which spot price was used.
  5. Ask whether the buyer is registered as a secondhand dealer. Chapter 538 requires registration under section 538.09.
  6. Keep your copy of the receipt for your tax records.

Selling gold in Jacksonville

At Edgewood Coin, 936 Edgewood Ave S, we buy gold and silver coins and bullion, broken and scrap gold jewelry, sterling silver and estate jewelry. We do not buy diamonds or gemstones, costume jewelry or silver plate. If you want to see how an offer is built before you decide, our Jacksonville gold-selling page explains the process, and appraisals of personal items are free. If you would rather hold metal than sell it, browse the online shop or start with our coin education section.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need ID to sell gold in Florida?

Yes. Florida law requires a secondhand dealer to verify a government-issued photo ID and record its type, issuer and number. The dealer also takes your right thumbprint and a signed ownership statement.

Why does a Florida dealer hold scrap gold for 30 days?

Section 538.06 bars a dealer from reselling, altering or disposing of scrap gold and silver, gemstones or jewelry for 30 calendar days after buying them. Bullion bars and coins are not subject to the hold. The hold gives law enforcement time to match transaction records against stolen property reports.

Do I pay Florida tax on the profit from selling gold?

No. Florida has no personal income tax. Federal tax can still apply: long-term gains on coins and metals are taxed as collectibles at a maximum of 28%, and short-term gains are taxed as ordinary income.

Will the dealer report my sale to the IRS?

Often not. Many precious metal sales fall below the thresholds that trigger a Form 1099-B. The 24-hour report to law enforcement is a theft-prevention record, not a tax filing, and you are still responsible for reporting any taxable gain.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Statute references are to the 2025 Florida Statutes, and IRS references are current as of November 2026. Talk to a tax professional about your own situation.

Sources: Florida Statutes s. 538.04; Florida Statutes s. 538.06; IRS Topic No. 409, Capital Gains and Losses; IRS Instructions for Form 1099-B; Florida Department of Revenue TIP 25A01-03; Florida Constitution, Art. VII, s. 5.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only. It is not financial, investment, legal or tax advice, and Edgewood Coin is not a licensed financial advisor. Tax rules depend on your situation and change over time, so consult your financial attorney or accountant before you sell, buy or make tax decisions. All investments, including gold, silver, platinum and coins, carry risk. Prices can fall as well as rise, and past performance does not guarantee future results.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Shopping Cart